Hairy Bob’s Cave – a Scarborough mystery
We posted some photos to our social media pages a few days ago of Hairy Bob’s Cave and asked who had visited it whilst in Scarborough, who had heard any of the myths about the cave and whether anyone knew anything concrete about it (no pun intended!). We thought we’d better follow that up with some information.
Hairy Bob’s Cave is located about half way around Royal Albert Drive, just behind the skate park (now named after the cave) and in the hillside beneath the castle headland. It’s a huge boulder which has been hollowed out to provide enough room to sit or lie down and has what appears to be a door and two windows carved into the front, looking out over North Bay.
They are various rumours about its origins. Some claim it was carved by ancient man and was some sort of habitation in times long past – this is very unlikely. Whilst the castle headland has been occupied for thousands of years and habitation on the top of the cliff dates back to the Bronze Age, our wonderful local Museum Trust have found absolutely no evidence of this cave being present. The carving of the door and windows is basic but indicates something more that neolithic tools were used.
Another myth is that it was created and occupied by a hermit in the early part of the 20th Century. Again, this seems like it is probably just a romantic story. Not only would it be incredibly small and uncomfortable (even by hermit standards!), there is, again, no documented evidence to support this. Some go further with this account and have stated that the cave was chiselled out by a local school boy (whether or not he was called Bob is unclear!) or, bizarrely, by one of the vergers of St Mary’s Parish Church!?
Could it be an entirely natural rock formation? Maybe. There are so many unusual cliffs and rocks along the coastline of the UK (see the Drinking Dinosaur at Flamborough Head) that we can’t entirely rule it out but the size and shape of the openings are so precise that is does seem to be manmade. There has not been flowing water on the cliff face in recent history and it’s unlikely that years of rainfall would hollow out the boulder so completely.
The most popular tales bring the mysterious ‘Hairy Bob’ into the mix. It is certain that there was indeed a family Bobb in Scarborough during this time and, that one of the family was known as Hairy Bob. Local accounts describe Hairy Bob as a dishevelled door-to-door salesman of ‘Yellowstone’ – sandstone harvested from the castle cliffs for use in the cleaning of doorsteps. Perhaps Hairy Bob built the cave as a shelter from the elements during his sandstone gathering shifts, though popular legend has it that Hairy Bob was a somewhat hen-pecked, mild-mannered fellow for whom the cave provided a den of solace away from the sharp tongue of his spouse.
The most likely tale suggests the cave is simply a makeshift bivouac against the often stormy North Sea waves, chiselled out by a shrewd worker employed in the construction of Royal Albert Drive which runs along the seafront. During storms and heavy weather, the crashing waves would no doubt have halted work on the road and the cave would have offered welcome refuge against the wind, waves and rain for the worker during such downtime. The road was formally completed in 1890.
One thing is known – the cave was definitely there in or around 1919 and appears not to have been much changed since then. The below shows what is thought to be the earliest photo of the cave, just behind a military tank which was presented to Scarborough Town in 1919 after the end of WWI.
Whether there is anything buried beneath the cave has never been discovered – could it be the secret entrance to much more below the surface?
Whatever the true origins (and it seems that if we don’t know now, we never will), it’s a quirky little addition to a stroll around the headland and a spark for the imagination of thousands of Scarborough visitors and locals alike.